1. Change the default folder view to Details, and allow one to set what one chooses under that to every kind of folder (i have hundreds, and know “apply to all..” is spssd to do it. Fixes for this do not stay – Google for threads).

2. Fix the problem with Vista not remembering Windows sizes (again, Google for problems with fixes)

3. Put the Up arrow back. It is often faster even after one learns the breadcrumb menu, and is needed when using folders without the navigation pane, which is helpful to eliminate due to Vista not rembering folder sizes. See free QTTab bar for this and more options worth incorporating.

4. Allow moving of Task Bar buttons, and choosing different colors, as well as saving sessions, just like Firefox allows for tabs (Colorful Tabs extension for the color). Then copy more things from FF for IE. Or retire it. (doing research, I usually run 2 instances of FF concurrently, one of Sea Monkey and 1 of others if needed, and find IE the least to be preferred)

5. Allow right click to copy whole path in the address bar of folders (ctrl and c will do it now). And allow the same for copying things for 3 d boxes.

6. easily allow hot keys for fast launching (with free AutoHotKey you can make scripts to launch one, or even many many apps, etc. simultaneously – closest thing to a session saver)

7 Provide a master list of everything in the Control Panel, etc, (things like C:\Windows\System32\powercfg.cpl) for faster access. Stat menue should seldom need to be used.

8. Greatly improve Speech to Text (and vice versa) and commands to do the above (and turn on, off PC, etc.) so you can just say things like , “Go to …”

9. Improve ability to see incoming and outgoing Internet traffic.

10. Can UAC, and use something like Winpatrol.

11. Add options to clipboard, to remember all (like clipboard diary)

12. Improve clock (colors, cpu load, free ram stats, etc.)

13. Allow changing file type icons on even basic versions of OS.

14. Put “copy to” and move to” as default options on right click menus (I have this).

15. Make it faster than Vista, which on a Dell E520 (3ghz cpu, 2.5gb ram) is slower than my W/98 (650mhz, 320mb ram) on basic tasks (navigating, opening folders), and slower than XP on the same PC. Even after tweaking and spare ram and low cpu load. (I do thank God for both, with Vista being overall better and more mature than XP)

#80 Alex says:
Why put another mouse button on a laptop? You already have four click modifier keys right next to the trackpad anyway.
—-
I let a student do their spreadsheet homework on my macbook using bootcamp. The homework software was written in flash and no matter what utility I found that make windows see modifier+click as right click, flash just would not respond properly.
But of course you’re just going to blame flash for that.
There are also quite a few games that need a 2nd mouse button and there isn’t always room to plug in and use a mouse when you’re on a bus or in a chartered plane.

chadseld said earlier, “Cut and Paste in finder/explorer breaks the cut and paste paradigm because the ‘cut’ does not remove the original item until it is pasted. This is different from the way cut works in a text editor.
—-
I would actually prefer _an option_ for text editors to work the other way. Select text, cut, the text changes color and starts gently fading in and out until you paste it or cut a different range of text.

#66 Kyle says:
#1: OS X is a terrible multi-monitor OS. I have 3 monitors, an open app’s menu bar can be over 2400 pixels away; this is simply poor design, at the very least allow a menu bar per monitor. The current bit of design cruft made sense when monitors were less than 500x and 9×9 or so, but the current menu bar model is just embarrassing.

#4: There are no utilities to resize windows automagically (like utils xp, keystrokes to make the window half the size of the monitor and snap to the left for instance)

#5: itunes is generally a piece of crap,
—-
ditto

#68 Wenzi says:
May I suggest you stop using a Mac. It would be better for all involved if you just went back to using a PC.
—-
…reminds me of a time when a little old lady politely suggested that I take my black ass back to africa. But I’m sure you didn’t mean to say that in the same unjustified, thoughtless and hateful way.

#53 actiondan says:
frankly both it and Windows should take a leaf out of Linux’s book. Having a drag motion to allow move/resize from anywhere within the window (eg Alt-left/middle drag in Gnome) is simple to learn and stupidly efficient. Why the hell to I have to search for a 1 pixel border/corner every time I want to rearrange my desktop?
–
QFT

#48 Guy says:
Well I think that finder should merge folders instead of replacing the old one with the new one. I recently bought a macbook and in the first couple of weeks, I lost two entire days work because I didn’t know that OSX didn’t merge.
–
Despite my best efforts I’ve had this happen more than 50 times in 5 years. Of those 50+ exactly 33 times it resulted in me losing at least 5 days of work. Before the end of the decade this “feature” will have caused me to lose 1 YEAR OF WORK!
Unfortunately I’ve never kept track of all the minutes(hours) wasted working around this “feature” by digging through folder after folder after folder, sorting by modified date and only copying the most recently edited files!

Wrong. In windows if you click a file and ‘cut’, its icon ‘fades’ out about 50%.
If you then click on another file and ‘cut’, the 1st file’s icon goes back to normal. It doe not disappear into the abyss. It’s fine.

All the hassle around drag / drop vs copy / paste just dissolves when you use a dual pane file manager (for example Xplorer2 by zabkat.com

Just put two folders next to each other (in a single application window), and you can choose whether to drag, paste .. or even use a single (copy/paste) shortcut eg ctrl+F6. Wildly obvious, once you get the picture.

i’d feel a whole lot better about switching to a mac if i knew there was an equivalent to Xplorer2 .. or if this was built into the Finder.

Most windows users have no idea about the enormous benefits from such an application ..
and this is something they have in common with most apple users.

Knock each other out ;-]

kind regards, michael

Right click on a folder and click properties. Ta-da! recursive file count.

1. Not being able to have an application take over the full screen so that you cannot click out of your current app by accident.
2. Resizing the window from any of its sides.
3. Not being able to use drop down lists with the arrow keys, i.e. in photoshop not being able to easily scan through multiple fonts by simply using the down arrow and see the changes on the selected font, instead having to click on each font, this is a real deficiency in lots of apps or just in the whole OS X environment, I am not sure which

Time was (and not long ago) that it seemed like it was Mac vs Windows fanwars all the time. Good to see we’re moving on: ‘While Windows and Mac users alike get a kick out of making fun of PC,…

1. Dual pane option for finder.

2. Drag a window from any edge. No brainer. Don’t even argue.

3. Don’t make me drag everything around all over the place.
Give me the option to work more quickly with less mousing — Cut and Paste.

4. Option to de-candy the entire interface. OS X, despite the hype has always been the sluggish OS in terms of responsiveness, by leagues compared to Windows on comparable hardware. Time to give us the option to cut the fat and make it more responsive. I want instant resposnse from everything in my interface, no bouncing, no flying, no delaying. Just response. When I click my cursor into a window or field, I want it there instantly because I’m instantly typing.

5. Just accept that there are users out there who aren’t drinking the kool-aid and just want to get work done, could care less about the users who worry about a feature being “ugly”, don’t care that much about animation or the appearance of chrome. People who just plain work on computers, and get their enjoyment/entertainment out in the real world. People who actually look at “Mac guy” on the commercials and don’t want to be like him, who find him smug and irritating.

6. (hardware) Give the notebooks two mouse buttons already. My Lord! How stubborn can you be?

My number one issue is the separation of the menu bar from application windows…in particular as I’m using an extended display / dual monitor off my MacBook. I keep thinking there’s got to be a way to keep it with the application Window but as of yet I’ve been able to find a hack. If I would have been aware of this before hand I probably wouldn’t have made the switch.

While the Mac has lots of better features than Windows…they seem to be in la la land on some basics. On the hardware side, I am still dumbfounded that MacBooks have no port replicator / docking stations.

Adam, it is windoze because compared to OS X, it is basic and primitive and guess what, Bill Gates doesnt care either but he sure as hell does care what Apple is doing because Vista is basically micro$oft’s copy of OS X…except with nothing done right.
And in-case you’re wondering, I have both a PC running windows and a mac but you can probably guess which I prefer.

2. It will never be windoze.

3. Steve Jobs does not care what you want from windoze.

4. If having to do a few things different bothers you so much, then…

5. Switch back to windoze.